Skip to main content

Winston as a fantasy for Orwell

 So. A LOT happened in this section. The worst thing Winston had done at the end of section one was write in his diary. Now he's having sex with Julia, working with the Brotherhood, and even drinking black market coffee! However, I'm quite dissatisfied with Orwell's depiction of Winston's path so far. Everything seems to fall perfectly into place for Winston, to the point where it seems wildly unrealistic given the setting. I think that Orwell has overly romanticized Winston's life, and thinks of Winston as a version of himself if he lived in Oceania.

Winston lives a pretty valiant life: he is an inconspicuous guy who fights against the government while conducting an affair with the most beautiful woman he knows. He knows it's only a matter of time before he gets found out, but this doesn't dissuade him from his life of rebellion. How upstanding of him. Perhaps the scene that irked me the most was when Winston and Julia go to O'Brien's flat to officially join the Brotherhood. Like, come on. The chances of things working out that perfectly are so ridiculously low. The way that Orwell lays everything out so nicely for Winston makes me think that Orwell has some sort of hero complex where he sees himself as Winston. This delusion hinders the plot of 1984, because I don't think there is any way that Winston could realistically find all the connections he finds/make it as far as he does without being vaporized.

Do you guys agree with me/see glimpses of Orwell's self-glorification in Winston's character?

Comments

  1. Alice Gao22 February 2021 at 07:36

    This. Yes. This post put into words my exact frustrations. But hah spoilers....(Winston gets arrested by the ThoughtPolice and it turns out his whole fantasy was a lie). That still doesn't change how Orwell wrote the book and might even further glorify Winston's little paradise. I think this could also be interpreted as the Party showing off their control of the system by fooling Winston into having hope and then completely crushing it. I prefer this interpretation, as it makes me less mad.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Prithika Ravi22 February 2021 at 07:39

    Yeah everything was moving a bit fast for my pace-- he goes from being scared to write in a diary to having regular meetings in a flat he rents out for that purpose. It also feels odd because as readers, we've become accustomed to figuratively always looking over our shoulders. Seeing Winston so relaxed is unnerving, and it really did feel like I was just waiting for the other shoe to drop.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Katelyn22 February 2021 at 07:50

    I think that in addition to what you've said in your post, another thing that has kind of bothered me is that Julia really doesn't seem to have much to do with the rebellion or the brotherhood at all. The way that Orwell treats Julia is truly just as a person for Winston to have sex with. She doesn't care very much about any sort of overarching, long-game rebellion and isn't really even given the time of day by O'Brien. She seems to be just another way to show the reader that Winston is "not alone", although O'Brien could've done that just as easily, I suppose.

    ReplyDelete
  4. L. Moffitt22 February 2021 at 07:55

    Oh I like this discussion! I think maybe this is one of the reasons 1984 has such lasting popularity -- it ends up being sort of a blueprint for all dystopian lit to come. Oddly I had similar feelings about Hunger Games -- I felt like Katniss was a fantasy figure, the only person (really?) who protested the Games and started a movement where everyone revered her.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

How Disney perpetuates voodoo stereotypes

In the opening chapters of Mumbo Jumbo , we've been introduced to Papa DaBas, a voodoo priest. In class we talked a bit about the largely negatively perception of voodoo in America. This immediately made me think of the Disney princess film, The Princess and the Frog . This movie is set in New Orleans, and follows a princess who falls in love, blah blah blah...but the villain is a voodoo-practicing witch doctor, Dr. Facilier.  I found it really interesting to look back at Dr. Facilier's character after discussing the American perception of voodoo, because Dr. Facilier is portrayed as a man of pure evil (here's a picture if you haven't seen the movie to show how creepy he is). His soul belongs to evil loas (his "friends on the other side", as he calls them), and he uses their power to achieve his greedy  goals, convincing the loas to continue working with him by feeding them the souls of innocent victims. He's manipulative and extremely powerful.  ...
8 comments
Read more

Paul D and Sethe's shared trauma

Paul D and Sethe have an extremely complicated relationship that constantly morphs and shifts throughout  Beloved . They spent lots of time at Sweet Home together, and therefore have an established emotional bond. Though a more physical aspect of their relationship develops, the glue holding them together is their shared trauma of living at Sweet Home and of their respective escapes. Generally speaking, relationships held together primarily by shared traumatic experiences are fragile and unstable: Paul D and Sethe's relationship is no exception. Though they understand each other's experiences with slavery, they have little else in common. Crucially, they haven't seen each other in eighteen years, and there are significant gaps in their knowledge what has happened in the other's life in the nearly two decades since their last encounter. Most importantly, Paul D is unaware of what Sethe did in the shed on that fateful day when schoolmaster came to 124. With the presen...
9 comments
Read more

Final thoughts

 Before I get into this, I want to start by pointing out that Jill was #1 on my most likely to die list, and she is the one who died. It feels wrong to congratulate myself, but I am a little bit proud. The ending was quite satisfying. It felt almost too good and peaceful for the end of such a wild and tragic novel. Nearly the entire group survived, they moved on from their ghosts of the past, and they have great resources that they can begin their Earthseed community with. I'm a little upset that Lauren is still in a relationship with Bankole, but it's good that there are so many relationships within their community as they plan for the future. The most surprising part of the ending was when Lauren discovered that Greyson, Emery, and their kids are all sharers. I was not expecting this at all, because sharing was Lauren's most unique trait. However, it does alienate her less from the rest of the group, and it makes the former slaves more united with the rest of the group. T...
Post a Comment
Read more